new gun....

[UtahProtectionForce]

hey all im thinking of maybe purchasing a new side arm, other then my glock, i like my glock but would like to purchase another so i can interchange my wep occasionally when going to the range, i am considering 3 others , i like striker systems over hammers, so at this time im considering

S&W sigma, 40. cal
Walther p99 40.cal
Sprigfeild xd 40. cal

i currently have a 9mm glock 17...

So which of these would you suggest over the others... i know i should practice first but am wondering of your opinions...

[SecTrainer]

Call me old, decrepit and throw me on the trash heap. I like to have at least one wheel gun and still actually prefer them over any semi's for simple operation, reliability as close to 100% as you can get, and ease of maintenance. I know the semi's carry more ammo, but at typical personal combat distances, I'll nail you with at least 5 out of 6 shots any day of the week unless you get the drop on me, and even if you do that I definitely have a better chance with a wheel gun.

Now, some argue that the pistol is more concealable, but I don't really think so. And, if you maintain the professional beer belly that all of us should constantly be striving to achieve, the difference will be unnoticeable anyway.

[Charger]

S&W sigma, 40. cal
Walther p99 40.cal
Sprigfeild xd 40. cal

NOTE: This is all personal opinion/experience, and should not be taken as factual.

I tried all 3 of those when I was shopping for a duty pistol a few years back. Personally, I'm not a fan of Glocks. I didn't like the way they felt in my hand at all. So those were instantly off my list. It's strange to me to see someone who actually LIKES a Glock considering the same weapons I came down to in my final decision-making process.. LOL The Springfield is a nice gun, but still felt a little too "Glockish" (is that a word? LOL) to me, so I passed on it.

I finally came down to the Sigma, and the P99. Both are MUCH more ergonomic, and easy to handle. In the end, I found the P99 to be more to my liking and made my choice. I've been nothing but happy with my P99 ever since. Extremely easy to use, accurate, and hasn't given me ANY problems in the years I've owned it. (My wife got it to smokestack ONCE, the first time she shot it. I have YET to get it to jam at all... I've owned it since 2002 and put PLENTY of rounds through it)

On a side note: I highly recommend you find a range that will let you rent these before you make a final choice. I've heard from other Walther owners that the 40 tends to have a stronger kick than my 9mm, so if you're intent on a 40 that may influence your decision a bit. Also, a lot of duty gear companies don't list holsters for the P99. Don't let them fool you, the holsters ARE out there. The size/shape is very similar to a HK USP, so they share many of the same holsters. I have the Uncle Mike's PRO-3 holster for mine. (Size 30 for the curious)

Hope this all helps!

[gcmc security part 2]

I have the P99 in .40 and love it. If I may make a suggestion take a look at the Smith and Wesson M&P available in .40. I recently put a deposit on one and plan on getting it off real soon! Can't wait!

[N. A. Corbier]

I haven't fired one yet, but the M&P .40 felt good in my hand with the large backstrap. I was at Streichers and the S&W rep showed me the entire M&P line, I liked what Stag Arms did for S&W, and I liked the way the M&P felt with the proper grips.

I also thought the Walther P22 was cool as hell, even if it was a 22 LR.

I went over to the Beretta tent, and I didn't like the way the new Beretta series felt. I think I'll go with M&P or XD when its time to buy one.

[mh892]

Call me old, decrepit and throw me on the trash heap. I like to have at least one wheel gun and still actually prefer them over any semi's for simple operation, reliability as close to 100% as you can get, and ease of maintenance. I know the semi's carry more ammo, but at typical personal combat distances, I'll nail you with at least 5 out of 6 shots any day of the week unless you get the drop on me, and even if you do that I definitely have a better chance with a wheel gun.

Now, some argue that the pistol is more concealable, but I don't really think so. And, if you maintain the professional beer belly that all of us should constantly be striving to achieve, the difference will be unnoticeable anyway.

I think your perfectly normal. I like my S&W 10, S&W 64. But I also like my S&W 39 at times.

If for some reason me and the wheel gun fall into the swamp I know I will come up shooting. Not so sure with the auto.

Now to find a 12 gauge wheel gun.

[gcmc security part 2]

I think your perfectly normal. I like my S&W 10, S&W 64. But I also like my S&W 39 at times.

If for some reason me and the wheel gun fall into the swamp I know I will come up shooting. Not so sure with the auto.

Now to find a 12 gauge wheel gun.

Hey, not sure where you live (I know you said you worked off 87), but I am trying to get some people together to go up to the range near Pace. I'm not a big fan of it, but it's the closest one to us Pcola people. PM me sometime.

[Charger]

I've heard nothing but good things about the new M&P series from S&W... A LOT of PDs are switching to them... Unfortunately, I haven't had a chance to hold/try one myself yet, but they sure are pretty!

My wife's looking for a new weapon as well right now... I'm trying to convince her to try out an M&P compact (she has tiny hands) when she goes to try some out... That way, I can play with it too.. LOL

[Chucky]

The Taurus 24/7 pro is the gun I would prefer if I had a choice but it is illegal in my state because it does not pass the round chambered drop test. Apparently it will fire if dropped from a 10 foot height on a cement floor. That aside watch the video and at the end the firing range is very impressive. The guy emptied a full clip and hit all targets in 1.4 seconds after the gun was used steady for 10.000 rounds then he set a new world record with the same pistol. The last time I checked it was under $500.00.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pDo0ua2IMp8

[Bill Warnock]

I've heard nothing but good things about the new M&P series from S&W... A LOT of PDs are switching to them... Unfortunately, I haven't had a chance to hold/try one myself yet, but they sure are pretty!

My wife's looking for a new weapon as well right now... I'm trying to convince her to try out an M&P compact (she has tiny hands) when she goes to try some out... That way, I can play with it too.. LOL

If your wife has "kleinhanz" look at the SigSauer .380, compact and easy to handle and shoot. At least let her get the feel of one.
Enjoy the day,
Bill

[Hank1]

Firearms that are too straight and angular in shape like the XD 9 and Glock are simply just not attractive in my opinion. There has to be some curves to it! Beyond feeling good in my hand, it has to look good too! I just love my SigSauer 2009. It is not as "boxey" looking I guess........

Be safe,

Hank

[SecTrainer]

If your wife has "kleinhanz" look at the SigSauer .380, compact and easy to handle and shoot. At least let her get the feel of one.
Enjoy the day,
Bill

That's their P232. Very nice gun, 17 oz with magazine (22 oz stainless, but I don't care for stainless anyway).

[ValleyOne]

In the end, I found the P99 to be more to my liking and made my choice. I've been nothing but happy with my P99 ever since. Extremely easy to use, accurate, and hasn't given me ANY problems in the years I've owned it.

I almost purchased the Walther, but the Beretta felt more comfortable and balanced. One area of concern I had with the Walther is the magazine release. I prefer the button type and the W I saw had a lever type contraption. Does this magazine release lever give you any troubles with gloves on? or wet? Or heck anytime? Is it ackward to re learn to slide down as opposed to push in?

[CAPTAIN KOOLAID]

New Firearm

Why not try the Beretta px4 strom has 3 back straps like the m&p but the strom doesn't have mag safty like the m&p . then there is Beretta 90 two not 92 . It has same grip and slide as the 92 but the frame is setup to take a tac lights, laser or combo.

[SEO_09]

"Now to find a 12 gauge wheel gun."

Will a 410 do? The Judge is chambered in 410, .45 LC. I think that it is kinda intimidating.